Pep Guardiola watched as Manchester City suffered a shock defeat in the 2025 FA Cup final. Crystal Palace secured their first-ever major trophy with a 1-0 win at Wembley, thanks to Eberechi Eze’s early goal. This loss means City will end the season without a trophy for the first time since Guardiola’s debut campaign in 2016-17.
A Season of Tactical Gambles
Guardiola’s tactical approach in the final drew immediate scrutiny. He abandoned his usual midfield dominance and instead set up City in a bold 4-2-3-1 formation, leaving out a recognized holding midfielder. This move evoked memories of previous high-profile defeats, such as the 2021 Champions League final, where a similar gamble backfired. The absence of key midfielders like Rodri and Mateo Kovacic left City exposed, especially on the counterattack.
The Penalty Switch: Who Decides?
One of the match’s most dramatic moments came when City were awarded a penalty after Bernardo Silva was fouled. Erling Haaland, usually the designated penalty taker, handed the ball to Omar Marmoush. Marmoush’s effort was saved by Palace goalkeeper Dean Henderson, a moment that proved pivotal.
After the match, Pep Guardiola clarified that he did not dictate the penalty taker. He explained that Haaland and Marmoush made the decision themselves on the pitch. Guardiola said, “I didn’t speak with them. They make a decision; penalties are like that. I like guys who take the initiative and decide. In that moment, it’s how they feel. They decided Omar was ready to take it”.
Dean Henderson’s Heroics and Controversy
Dean Henderson was central to the narrative of the final. He not only saved the penalty but also made several crucial stops to keep City at bay. The match was not without controversy. In the first half, Henderson handled the ball outside his area under pressure from Haaland but avoided a red card after a VAR review. Guardiola was visibly upset after the final whistle and confronted Henderson, reportedly telling him, “You didn’t deserve that. Disgrace”.
City’s Missed Chances and Palace’s Defensive Masterclass
Manchester City dominated possession and created numerous chances but could not find a way past Henderson and a resolute Palace defence. Despite their attacking efforts, City’s finishing let them down, and Palace’s tactical discipline under manager Oliver Glasner proved decisive. Glasner’s side soaked up pressure and struck clinically on the counter, with Eze’s volley sealing a historic win.
Pep Guardiola’s Reflections
After the match, Pep Guardiola congratulated Crystal Palace and acknowledged the disappointment of the result. He expressed satisfaction with his team’s performance but lamented their inability to convert chances. Guardiola said, “We created a lot, but we didn’t score, and that’s why we could not win”. He refused to dwell on the controversial moments, insisting there were no excuses for the defeat.
The End of an Era?
This FA Cup final loss marks a significant moment in Pep Guardiola’s Manchester City tenure. The defeat capped a season where City lost their grip on domestic dominance and finished without silverware. Critics have questioned Guardiola’s tactical decisions, especially his tendency to “overthink” in crucial matches. The spotlight now falls on how Pep Guardiola will respond and rebuild for the next campaign.